Christian Indie Publishing Association Christian Indie Publishing Association

Serving Independent Authors and Small Publishers

Menu

When deadlines and pressure overwhelm you, do you really need to worry about the punctuation in your writing? Yes. Readers needs to understand your message, and punctuation has a fundamental part in this responsibility. One punctuation mark that clearly demonstrates this is the comma—specifically, the Oxford comma.

What Is the Oxford Comma?

The Oxford comma is the last comma in a series. For example, “I need to buy staples, pens, and pencils.” The comma after pens is the Oxford comma, also called the Harvard comma or serial comma.

The Oxford comma promotes readability, understanding, and clarity. In the example sentence above, I could delete the Oxford comma, and the sentence would not lose its meaning. Some sentences, however, require the Oxford comma to avoid ambiguity. Consider the following sentence: “I told my siblings, Drew, and Amelia.” If I removed the Oxford comma, the reader may conclude that Drew and Amelia are my siblings, but that would be incorrect. The Oxford comma changes the meaning of my sentence and my readers’ understanding of it.

Journalists and publishers hold varying opinions on the Oxford comma. Some publications promote its use in all cases, while other publications permit it only when its absence would create confusion.

Arguments for the Oxford Comma

There are several arguments supporting the Oxford comma. Although the Oxford comma is still widely used, several writers argue that it should be removed. I believe, however, that the Oxford comma should be used for several reasons.

1. The Oxford comma prevents confusion.

The Oxford comma, as demonstrated earlier, prevents confusion by separating the last two items in a series. Although conjunctions (and, or, etc.) negate the need for a comma, the Oxford comma’s absence can cause ambiguity. As writers, we must ensure that our words and meaning are clear. If we can prevent misinterpretation, we must do so.

The Oxford comma may not seem to be a big deal, but its absence can cause costly misunderstanding. In the 2014 case O’Connor v. Oakhurst Dairy, truck drivers for Maine’s Oakhurst Dairy Company filed a lawsuit against the company. They stated that they were entitled to overtime pay for their work.

Maine’s overtime legislation stated that overtime pay did not apply to the following:

“The canning, processing, preserving, freezing, drying, marketing, storing, packing for shipment or distribution of:

(1) Agricultural produce;

(2) Meat and fish products; and

(3) Perishable foods.”

The missing Oxford comma after shipment indicated to many readers that packing for shipment or distribution was one action, not two. The drivers argued that “packing for shipment or distribution” is not the same as “distribution,” the work that they were doing. Therefore, they believed they were entitled to overtime pay for their work of distribution. A district court initially ruled in Oakhurst Dairy’s favor, but the drivers appealed to the First Circuit. This court reversed the previous decision. The Oakhurst Dairy Company settled out of court—costing the company $5 million, which they paid to over one hundred drivers.

Maine’s legislature updated the overtime section to the following:

“The canning; processing; preserving; freezing; drying; marketing; storing; packing for shipment; or distributing of:

(1) Agricultural produce;

(2) Meat and fish products; and

(3) Perishable foods.”


The difference in punctuation (and the change from distribution to distributing) eliminates the original confusion and indicates the intended meaning.

Although this is an extreme case, this lawsuit proves the importance of the Oxford comma. Ambiguity can cost companies time, money, and their readers’ trust. Is brevity really more important than clarity?

2. The Oxford comma is promoted by Chicago, MLA, AMA, and APA.

Style guides are used by writers in publishing, journalism, and academic writing to ensure correctness and to maintain consistency. The Oxford comma is promoted by the following noteworthy style guides:

  • Chicago Manual of Style: This style is typically used for literary writing.
  • Modern Language Association of America (MLA) Style: This style is used in research and scholarly work for literature and related fields.
  • American Medical Association (AMA) Style: This style is used in medical journals and publications.
  • American Psychological Association (APA) Style: This style is used in many scientific papers for medicine and psychology.

These style guides are used for different forms of writing, but they all advise writers to use the Oxford comma. Through a wide range of subjects, the Oxford comma remains important for consistency and clarity. We must consider the importance of the Oxford comma because these notable guides recommend it.

3. The Oxford comma is promoted by Strunk and White’s Elements of Style.

William Strunk, Jr., and E.B. White’s The Elements of Style is a little book with a large influence. The book, now in its fourth edition, has been used as a classroom guide and textbook for decades. In their book, Strunk and White instruct, “In a series of three or more terms with a single conjunction, use a comma after each term except the last.” This instruction, found in the “Elementary Rules of Usage” section, is a fundamental grammar rule, and it has been taught to students for generations. To remove this rule or to follow it inconsistently would create avoidable miscommunication.

4. The Oxford comma rule should be followed consistently.

Some style guides advise writers to include the Oxford comma only when it is necessary to avoid misreadings. But shouldn’t writers be consistent? Why follow a rule sometimes but not other times? Moreover, who decides when the Oxford comma is necessary for readability? Many times, authors write a sentence that seems understandable to them but confuses readers. A writer may believe the Oxford comma to be unnecessary, but he cannot guarantee that his audience will read a sentence the same way he does.

Consistently using the Oxford comma ensures clarity and understanding—every time.

Arguments Against the Oxford Comma

Many writers omit the Oxford comma for brevity and uniformity in their writing. I support the Oxford comma, but there are valid arguments against its use.

1. The Oxford comma is not recommended by AP Style or CP Style.

Several style guides support the Oxford comma, as mentioned above. Other style guides, however, advise against it:

  • Associated Press (AP) Style: This style guide is used for journalism and directs journalists to omit the Oxford comma for brevity. Almost all American news sources use this style, including The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, Fox News, and CNN.
  • Canadian Press (CP) Style: This style is used in Canadian journalism and also advises writers against using the Oxford comma.

These style guides permit the Oxford comma to avoid ambiguity, but otherwise do not recommend the Oxford comma. Because journalism, one of the most prominent writing forms, omits the Oxford comma, there is strong support to omit the Oxford comma.

2. Removing the Oxford comma promotes brevity.

Many writers who do not use the Oxford comma argue that its omission promotes brevity. This idea is supported by the Oxford comma’s absence in journalism and similar publications. Often, the Oxford comma is unnecessary, and the sentence’s meaning remains the same without it. When character space is limited, writers may forgo the extra comma.

3. Strong writing prevents the need for the Oxford comma.

Another argument against the Oxford comma is that strong writing prevents misunderstanding and the need for the extra comma. If writers use varied structure, clear words, and punctuation marks such as colons and semicolons, the Oxford comma becomes redundant.

How the Oxford Comma Affects Your Writing

What does this debate have to do with your writing? Why should you care about the pesky little Oxford comma?

First, you need to pick one method and stick to it. As you write your piece, choose to either use the Oxford comma or not use it. Including the Oxford comma in some areas of your work but neglecting it in other areas creates confusion. For the reader, this inconsistency indicates poor editing.

Second, you need to follow your organization’s usage rules. If you write for a publishing company or other organization, you must follow their grammar and formatting rules. Neglecting your organization’s grammar rules reflects poorly on you as the writer and creates more work for the editor (whether that be you or someone else).

Finally, your writing must be clear. Whether you use the Oxford comma is up to you, but it is your job to write stories that are understandable. If you believe your writing is clearer with the Oxford comma, then use it. If you think your writing is stronger without it, then stick to that method.

About the Author

Brenna Collier is a senior in college pursuing a Bachelor of Arts in Professional Writing. In her free time, she enjoys reading, traveling, and visiting local coffee shops. After she graduates, Brenna plans to use her degree to glorify God through His gift of writing.

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X

Tags : author, Christian author, Christian writer, writing

Category : Publishing, Self-Publishing, Writing

Share your thoughts Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

When Publishing Metrics Become a Spiritual Scoreboard
menu
  • Home
  • About
  • Membership
    • Join/Renew
    • Directory
    • Partner Members
    • FAQ
  • Writer’s Conference
  • Blog
  • Publishing Opportunities
  • Trade Shows
  • Testimonials
  • Networking
    • Facebook Group
    • Mastermind Groups
    • Christian Writers Group
  • Resources
  • SHOP
    • Bookstore
    • Author Coaching
    • Author Products
    • Determine Book Categories/Keywords
  • Book Award
  • Contact
  • Login
About Susan

How to self-publish a book 2Susan Neal RN, MBA, MHS is a Certified AWSA Writer Coach, author of seven healthy living books, and a self-published number one Amazon best seller. Let Susan show you how her experience and robust knowledge makes her an ideal coach for indie authors and small publishers.

Latest Posts
  • Why Book Awards Have Lasting Value
    Why Book Awards Have Lasting Value Gripping hands and […]
  • How to Go From Awful First Draft to Wonderful Revision
    How to Go From Awful First Draft to Wonderful Revision […]
  • Reaching a Generation of Readers through Christian Books
    Reaching a Generation of Readers through Christian […]
Follow Us on Twitter
Twitter feed is not available at the moment.
Search CIPA
.


Social

2020 Copyright © Christian Indie Publishing Association

  • About
  • Membership
  • Contact
  • Privacy